A syllogism is two premises and a conclusion, e. g.:
All men are mortal;
Socrates is a man;
Therefore, Socrates is mortal.
A Hegelian triad is a thesis, an antithesis and a synthesis. e. g.:
being;
nothing;
becoming.
Imaginative fantasy is written within a syllogism or triad, e. g.:
the Golden Age of Baghdad, complete with jinns, flying carpets etc, existed exactly as described in the 1001 Nights;
Baghdad is now as we know it from the news;
so what happened?
Neil Gaiman presents a conclusion or synthesis in The Sandman: Ramadan.
Michael Moran remembers that he was Miracleman in the fifties and early sixties;
the world in the eighties was how we experienced it at the time with no knowledge or record of any Miracleman;
so where did Michael's memories come from?
The dialogue in Miracleman, no 1 (New York, 2014), expresses Michael's and Liz's bewilderment -
Liz: ...that's just so stupid!
Michael: I suppose you're right. Actually saying it out loud like that, it does sound...well...pretty unlikely. I never really thought about it before. But I had to believe it, don't you see? I was Miracleman. I was a being of almost unlimited power!!
Michael (later): This may, damn it...This does sound silly in 1982, but in the fifties it made perfect sense. This is how I remember it. This is how it happened. (p. 23)
Two realities meet and interact so what will happen next? The first thing that happens is that Michael shouts, "Damn you, Liz, you're laughing at my life!!" (p. 24) and puts his fist through the solid oak floor and she believes.
Showing posts sorted by date for query Baghdad. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Baghdad. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Saturday, 18 January 2014
Thursday, 19 December 2013
Ramadan
Two posts ago, here, I did forget to list one of the Sandman stories that is a story told by a character within the story. The last page of "Ramadan" in Fables And Reflections reveals that the story of the Golden Age of Baghdad has been told to the crippled boy Hassan by a story teller amidst the ruins and rubble of the bomb-sites of modern Baghdad.
The story begins:
"In the name of Allah,
"the compassionate,
"the all-merciful,
"I tell my tale.
"For there is no god but Allah,
"and Mohammed is his prophet." (p. 227)
The last page informs us that Allah has been invoked neither by the author nor by an invisible narrator but by a story teller who ends his narration for the day because Hassan has no more coins or cigarettes to pay him with. Hassan asks, "How could the city last?" but then goes home "...by child's short-cuts..." with, behind his eyes, "...towers and jewels and djinn, carpets and rings and wild afreets, kings and princes and cities of brass..." (p. 258). That is how the city lasts.
Gaiman's fictional premise was: if the wondrous city of Baghdad really did exist exactly as described in the legends, then what happened to it and where is it now? Knowing that all things pass, Haroun asked Morpheus to make his city last and the only way to do this was to remove it from the world of fact into the realm of dreams and stories. Haroun sleeps on a no-longer-flying carpet in the market place and wakes to a mundane Baghdad. His forgotten original city now exists in a bottle in a trunk in the Dreaming, in the story teller's tales and in Hassan's head.
Having summoned Morpheus, Haroun asks him:
"Are you, then, the lord of sleep, the prince of stories, he to whom Allah has given dominion over that which is not, and was not, and shall never be?" (p. 245)
A Muslim must express it like this and Morpheus does not take issue with his theology but they also say that "...there is no god but Allah..." and we have seen many.
The story begins:
"In the name of Allah,
"the compassionate,
"the all-merciful,
"I tell my tale.
"For there is no god but Allah,
"and Mohammed is his prophet." (p. 227)
The last page informs us that Allah has been invoked neither by the author nor by an invisible narrator but by a story teller who ends his narration for the day because Hassan has no more coins or cigarettes to pay him with. Hassan asks, "How could the city last?" but then goes home "...by child's short-cuts..." with, behind his eyes, "...towers and jewels and djinn, carpets and rings and wild afreets, kings and princes and cities of brass..." (p. 258). That is how the city lasts.
Gaiman's fictional premise was: if the wondrous city of Baghdad really did exist exactly as described in the legends, then what happened to it and where is it now? Knowing that all things pass, Haroun asked Morpheus to make his city last and the only way to do this was to remove it from the world of fact into the realm of dreams and stories. Haroun sleeps on a no-longer-flying carpet in the market place and wakes to a mundane Baghdad. His forgotten original city now exists in a bottle in a trunk in the Dreaming, in the story teller's tales and in Hassan's head.
Having summoned Morpheus, Haroun asks him:
"Are you, then, the lord of sleep, the prince of stories, he to whom Allah has given dominion over that which is not, and was not, and shall never be?" (p. 245)
A Muslim must express it like this and Morpheus does not take issue with his theology but they also say that "...there is no god but Allah..." and we have seen many.
Sunday, 12 August 2012
Politics And Dream II
Augustus' power could not prevent him from wanting the Empire to decline.
Haroun al Raschid's power could not make the fabulous age of Baghdad last forever in the waking world.
Robespierre could not kill a myth.
An Indian king killed his wife and her lover but had not been able to prevent them from becoming lovers.
Prez the Teen President achieved the seemingly impossible but was not President forever.
Shakespeare helped to translate the King James Bible but really worked for the King of Dreams.
The Emperor of the United States wielded no power but captured the popular imagination.
It is better to prevent ecclesiastical and political power from combining.
The story about Haroun al Raschid, "Ramadan" in Sandman 50, is a perfect example of an imaginative writer spinning a story from what seems like an obvious premise when it is stated. If we imagine that the fabulous age of Baghdad once existed exactly as described, then why is it not still here now?
Saturday, 4 August 2012
Politics And Dream
Augustus hides from the gods by dressing as a beggar.
The fabulous Baghdad endures but only in dreams.
Robespierre bans myths but meets Orpheus.
A madman becomes Emperor of the United States.
The fabulous Baghdad endures but only in dreams.
Robespierre bans myths but meets Orpheus.
A madman becomes Emperor of the United States.
Shakespeare translates Psalms for the King James Bible.
But he really works for the King of Dreams.
He speaks disrespectfully of James to his daughter.
And he hides his name in a Psalm.
But he really works for the King of Dreams.
He speaks disrespectfully of James to his daughter.
And he hides his name in a Psalm.
A teenager becomes US President, then a myth.
A Parliament of Rooks sometimes kills the single rook who addresses it.
A Chinese Imperial adviser is exiled.
In other realms, Lucifer retires and Titania's Ambassador prevents a powerful alliance.
A Parliament of Rooks sometimes kills the single rook who addresses it.
A Chinese Imperial adviser is exiled.
In other realms, Lucifer retires and Titania's Ambassador prevents a powerful alliance.
Only the Imperial adviser is invented by Gaiman. The characters from Augustus to Shakespeare are historical. The teen President was a fictitious character in DC Comics. Rooks, Lucifer and Titania are known from other sources.
Embittered against his great uncle and patron, Julius Caesar, Augustus, who has brought peace to the Roman Empire, plans not its expansion but its decline. His plan must be concealed from the divine Julius and the Olympian gods but will please Terminus, the god of boundaries, who had asked Morpheus to intervene in Augustus' dreams. If the historical Augustus had hidden in the market place to plot secretly against the gods, then we would say that the gods were in his imagination but, because Sandman is fantasy, we are invited to imagine that they are real.
Despite his apparently unlimited political power, Haroun Al Raschid can ensure the endurance of the Golden Age of Baghdad only by giving it to Morpheus. Thus, that Age passes from the waking realm of experience and memory to Morpheus' realm of dreams and imaginings. When the transaction is completed, Haroun sees a stranger, Morpheus, carrying an ingeniously devised but no longer for sale city in a bottle. He remembers living not in a fabulous city but in a mundane town where his former flying carpet lies abandoned in the market place. But the fabulous city lives in the mind of a crippled boy listening to a story teller among the bomb sites and rubble of modern Baghdad.
Robespierre and Orpheus represent reason and imagination in unnecessary conflict.
Because Joshua Norton was insane, his imperial rank existed only in his imagination. However, it also caught the popular imagination so that many restaurants accepted his currency and his funeral procession was over two miles long. Here, amazingly, Gaiman recounts not fiction but history. However, because The Sandman is fantasy, we see the historical "Emperor" and the fictitious "Prez" (below) meeting personified Death. The common theme is imagination.
In exchange for the power to give men lasting dreams, Shakespeare writes A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Tempest for Morpheus. Shakespeare's company performs the Dream for Oberon and Titania before they leave this world. Morpheus wanted a play about a man who turns his back on magic.
Gaiman makes the teen President a slightly less incredible figure. He is elected three months short of his twentieth birthday so is a teenage President for only three months. But then he becomes a legend. He averts the energy crisis and stops the arms race. After he has left the White House, he is known only through stories, not through facts. After his death, he walks between the worlds looking for Americas to fix. Like the fabulous Baghdad, Prez transcends the real world.
Why the rooks kill one of their number is a mystery but the Biblical Abel, now living in the Dreaming, reveals that the lone rook finds out whether the others liked its story.
The Imperial adviser crosses a desert where travelers see (or imagine) many things. Morpheus offers him an advisory role but he opts to obey his own Emperor and continue his journey into exile. His seditious son's magic did not protect the son from execution. A modern response would be that magic is imaginary. Another response is that the Emperor's magic was more powerful.
Lucifer's resignation is a case of things changing yet remaining the same. He retires because he tires of presiding over the pointless, self-inflicted anguish of the damned. In this hereafter, the deceased experience the conditions that they expect. Hell is how they had imagined it. Lucifer not only leaves Hell but, before leaving, empties it by expelling demons and damned. However, a higher authority decrees that they must return. But there is longer term change because Hell is now ruled by angels who ensure that the suffering is neither pointless nor punitive but purgative.
The story of Titania's Ambassador is told by the Ambassador himself and at least partly a product of his imagination.
We see Augustus, Haroun and Robespierre not only in different months but even in different calendars:
the Roman Imperial August;
the Muslim Ramadan;
the French Revolutionary Thermidor.
the Muslim Ramadan;
the French Revolutionary Thermidor.
The Sandman shows us prehistoric Africa, ancient Greece, magicians, writers, Asgard, the Inn of the Worlds' End, the Sea Serpent, the handsome cabin boy, retired deities and super heroines, dead school boys, a young pop singer, an immortal Englishman, the triple Goddess, a serial killers' convention, Clark Kent and the Gotham City vigilante meeting at Dream's Wake and a skerry of Dreams. It imaginatively addresses universal humanity and immanent divinity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



