See here.
Andrea argues that:
the characters time travel from the present of Reality A to the past of Reality B and return to the present of Reality A;
Thanos follows some of the heroes from the past of Reality B to the present of Reality A;
therefore, the only discrepancy is that, if Rogers remained in the past of Reality B, then he should have aged into the present of B, not A.
I think it also follows that Thanos' disappearance from Reality B prevents V in B?
Showing posts sorted by date for query time travel. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query time travel. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Wednesday, 12 June 2019
Sunday, 28 April 2019
The Time Travel Problem In Avengers: Endgame II
See The Time Travel Problem In Avengers: Endgame I, here.
Just before V, Thanos detects the activities of one of the superhero teams that have traveled from 6 AV to times before V in order to extract the Stones;
following this clue, Thanos travels to 6 AV, arriving shortly after the teams have returned;
all those who had been dissolved at V are restored;
Thanos and all his forces are dissolved.
Therefore, in this timeline, Thanos, having been dissolved in 6 AV:
does not travel back to just before V;
does not cause V;
does not live on another planet from V until 5 AV;
is not killed on that planet by Thor.
Yet these events have happened in this timeline in which Thanos arrives in 6 AV.
Contradiction.
Just before V, Thanos detects the activities of one of the superhero teams that have traveled from 6 AV to times before V in order to extract the Stones;
following this clue, Thanos travels to 6 AV, arriving shortly after the teams have returned;
all those who had been dissolved at V are restored;
Thanos and all his forces are dissolved.
Therefore, in this timeline, Thanos, having been dissolved in 6 AV:
does not travel back to just before V;
does not cause V;
does not live on another planet from V until 5 AV;
is not killed on that planet by Thor.
Yet these events have happened in this timeline in which Thanos arrives in 6 AV.
Contradiction.
The Time Travel Problem In Avengers: Endgame 1
At the end of Avengers: Infinity War, Thanos uses the Stones to cause 50% of living beings throughout the universe to dissolve into dust. For convenience, let us call this mass dissolution the "Vanishment"(V), let us call years after V "AV" and let us call events immediately before V "just before V."
In Avengers: Endgame (I might not have all of these events in exactly the right order):
five years elapse so we get to 5 AV;
surviving superheroes find Thanos on another planet and Thor kills Thanos;
Ant Man, who had not dissolved but had been trapped in the quantum realm for five objective years but five subjective hours (?), returns to the macrocosm;
he suggests -
superhero teams travel to times before V when it would be possible for each team to extract one of the Stones and bring them to the present which is now some time after 5 AV, say 6 AV;
use the Stones to restore all the people who had been dissolved but do this in 6 AV;
return each Stone to the moment from which it had been extracted.
Thus, the past would not be changed: the history of each Stone would be uninterrupted and the six years between V and 6 AV would not be affected.
What is wrong with this plan?
In Avengers: Endgame (I might not have all of these events in exactly the right order):
five years elapse so we get to 5 AV;
surviving superheroes find Thanos on another planet and Thor kills Thanos;
Ant Man, who had not dissolved but had been trapped in the quantum realm for five objective years but five subjective hours (?), returns to the macrocosm;
he suggests -
superhero teams travel to times before V when it would be possible for each team to extract one of the Stones and bring them to the present which is now some time after 5 AV, say 6 AV;
use the Stones to restore all the people who had been dissolved but do this in 6 AV;
return each Stone to the moment from which it had been extracted.
Thus, the past would not be changed: the history of each Stone would be uninterrupted and the six years between V and 6 AV would not be affected.
What is wrong with this plan?
Saturday, 27 April 2019
Avengers: Endgame
An ultimate feel good film. Also, an ultimate snatching victory from the jaws of apparent defeat film.
A serious attempt is made to avoid time travel contradictions. However, if the stones had to be returned to the moments from which they had been taken, then surely the same should apply to Thanos? And his memory of his trip through time should have been erased?
I had to run in and out during the credits so I do not know whether there was a mid-credits scene but will ask. It was good to sit till the end of the credits even though there was no post-credits scene. All those people deserve to have their names seen and some of the information is interesting.
Clint loses Natasha but gets his family back. Contrast this with what happens to these characters in The Ultimates. (Scroll down.)
It feels like the interminable movieverse finally went somewhere. It had legs. We now know who we will not see again.
A serious attempt is made to avoid time travel contradictions. However, if the stones had to be returned to the moments from which they had been taken, then surely the same should apply to Thanos? And his memory of his trip through time should have been erased?
I had to run in and out during the credits so I do not know whether there was a mid-credits scene but will ask. It was good to sit till the end of the credits even though there was no post-credits scene. All those people deserve to have their names seen and some of the information is interesting.
Clint loses Natasha but gets his family back. Contrast this with what happens to these characters in The Ultimates. (Scroll down.)
It feels like the interminable movieverse finally went somewhere. It had legs. We now know who we will not see again.
Saturday, 25 February 2017
In Smallville Season 9
We are told that Lois Lane visits the future and returns three weeks later with no memories of the future. The present is not a place that can be returned to three weeks later. It is the time from which she departed and she did not return to that time. She traveled three weeks into the future, which would explain why she had no memories from any further future.
Of course, we are later told that she did travel a year into the future. While she is in that future, Clark tells her to travel back into the past and prevent this future. He cannot coherently believe that the moment in which he is speaking and which therefore exists can be prevented from existing.
A Justice Society that was so low key that Daily Planet reporters had never heard of it? They are shown with perfect fidelity to the originals.
Of course, we are later told that she did travel a year into the future. While she is in that future, Clark tells her to travel back into the past and prevent this future. He cannot coherently believe that the moment in which he is speaking and which therefore exists can be prevented from existing.
A Justice Society that was so low key that Daily Planet reporters had never heard of it? They are shown with perfect fidelity to the originals.
Tuesday, 7 February 2017
Smallville: Doomsday
I watched Smallville: Doomsday, then had to read a summary to make sense of it but it does make sense.
Henry James Olsen dies but his younger brother, "Jimmie" Olsen, will become a Daily Planet photographer. This is a recognized alternative fictional form of the death and resurrection myth. Henry James Olsen dies knowing that Clark was the Red-Blue Blur but not knowing "Superman."
Time Travel Issues
Superman inspired the Legion in the 31st century;
Rokk, a Legionnaire, time travels to the 21st century to visit Clark Kent before he became Superman;
Rokk returns to a 31st century in which history records that Clark died early, on a particular date, and there was no Superman;
Rokk returns to the 21st century to warn Clark and to try to change history back.
In the altered 31st century, was there:
no Legion?
no Rokk?
or a different version of Rokk who never joined a Legion and never time traveled to the 21st century?
Will Rokk get his original 31st century back or a third version?
Will he have duplicated himself by changing events?
Henry James Olsen dies but his younger brother, "Jimmie" Olsen, will become a Daily Planet photographer. This is a recognized alternative fictional form of the death and resurrection myth. Henry James Olsen dies knowing that Clark was the Red-Blue Blur but not knowing "Superman."
Time Travel Issues
Superman inspired the Legion in the 31st century;
Rokk, a Legionnaire, time travels to the 21st century to visit Clark Kent before he became Superman;
Rokk returns to a 31st century in which history records that Clark died early, on a particular date, and there was no Superman;
Rokk returns to the 21st century to warn Clark and to try to change history back.
In the altered 31st century, was there:
no Legion?
no Rokk?
or a different version of Rokk who never joined a Legion and never time traveled to the 21st century?
Will Rokk get his original 31st century back or a third version?
Will he have duplicated himself by changing events?
Tuesday, 31 January 2017
"Long Live The Legion!"
I remembered that Chloe was supposed to have forgotten Clark's secret but I forgot that she had been abducted by Doomsday! And anyone reading this blog will have seen Smallville years ago and forgotten the sequence of events.
The Legion are great! I remember their first appearance in Adventure Comics. Metafiction: in Smallville, the Legion has never heard of Chloe Sullivan. Well, they had never heard of her before.
The Legion ring that Rokk gives to Clark is just for time travel so he should not be able to use it to reverse events as he does in "Infamous." Either do time travel well or don't do it.
The Legion are great! I remember their first appearance in Adventure Comics. Metafiction: in Smallville, the Legion has never heard of Chloe Sullivan. Well, they had never heard of her before.
The Legion ring that Rokk gives to Clark is just for time travel so he should not be able to use it to reverse events as he does in "Infamous." Either do time travel well or don't do it.
Monday, 30 January 2017
Smallville: Infamous
OK. I realize that I have accidentally skipped over the "Legion" episode, which is probably why I am having a problem with continuity. However, if what Clark does with the Legion ring is time travel, then he should coexist with his younger self when he travels to the past. And, if it is not time travel but literally rewinding the rest of the universe around him - this has happened before in Smallville -, then it is even more absurd.
Smallville has had good dramatic situations with the main characters but it did not need Maxima and does not need "changing the past."
Smallville has had good dramatic situations with the main characters but it did not need Maxima and does not need "changing the past."
Monday, 26 December 2016
Christmas Presents
For Christmas, I have received Smallville Season 8 and Alan Moore's second novel. This author, Moore, has written that character, Superman. It is appropriate to remember Moore's "Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow?" while beginning to appreciate his Jerusalem, which Michael Moorcock describes as "...the great British novel." (back cover)
This novel has a comic strip-like cover, three black and white photographs and somewhere around 1160 pages of very small print. Its central idea is a view of time called Eternalism. Moore states in his Acknowledgments that Fay Dowker is currently researching an alternative hypothesis. I am interested both in Alan Moore's writing and in the philosophy of time - not only the concept of time travel but also the nature of time - so I expect to study the text of Jerusalem closely while also reading sf and watching superhero dvds. Moore quotes Elizabeth Anscombe quoting Wittgenstein.
Time is elastic in Pellucidar or Skartartis. Mike Grell has Travis Morgan visit Oliver Queen whom he resembles. The fantasy element of Skartaris is played down but just enough is said to contradict the usually realistic tone of Grell's Green Arrow.
Onward, Earthlings.
This novel has a comic strip-like cover, three black and white photographs and somewhere around 1160 pages of very small print. Its central idea is a view of time called Eternalism. Moore states in his Acknowledgments that Fay Dowker is currently researching an alternative hypothesis. I am interested both in Alan Moore's writing and in the philosophy of time - not only the concept of time travel but also the nature of time - so I expect to study the text of Jerusalem closely while also reading sf and watching superhero dvds. Moore quotes Elizabeth Anscombe quoting Wittgenstein.
Time is elastic in Pellucidar or Skartartis. Mike Grell has Travis Morgan visit Oliver Queen whom he resembles. The fantasy element of Skartaris is played down but just enough is said to contradict the usually realistic tone of Grell's Green Arrow.
Onward, Earthlings.
Thursday, 2 April 2015
J'onn J'onzz
J'onn J'onzz, John Jones, the Martian Manhunter, seems to have all the Kryptonian powers except the ability to traverse space plus several more:
telepathy;
invisibilty;
impalpability;
metamorphosis.
In a British black and white reprint annual in the 1960's, I saw him exercise the power to extinguish a fire inside a building by liquefying the skylight above the fire with beams from his eyes. In those days, he remained invisible and operated in secret.
Next, I saw him visible, tangible and green in the Justice League of America and in a Detective Comics back up feature. Later, he rejoined his fellow Martians in their extrasolar colony on New Mars, a clear recognition that Mars is in fact not inhabited. Later still, we learned that:
his original Martian form was not as we see him;
he had not only teleported but also time traveled from an inhabited Mars in the distant past, just as Michael Moorcock's Michael Kane had had to time travel pastward to reach an inhabited Mars.
When J'onzz got his own series, his metamorphic power was developed fully for the first time, giving him multiple identities on Earth. In a black identity, he worked on the Kent farm to keep an eye on Kal-El, as he does in Smallville. In The Sandman, he sees Morpheus as a Martian deity.
Apparently it will emerge that he had been an inter-galactic manhunter working with Jor-El. Smallville: Labyrinth alludes to his Martian vulnerability to fire.
telepathy;
invisibilty;
impalpability;
metamorphosis.
In a British black and white reprint annual in the 1960's, I saw him exercise the power to extinguish a fire inside a building by liquefying the skylight above the fire with beams from his eyes. In those days, he remained invisible and operated in secret.
Next, I saw him visible, tangible and green in the Justice League of America and in a Detective Comics back up feature. Later, he rejoined his fellow Martians in their extrasolar colony on New Mars, a clear recognition that Mars is in fact not inhabited. Later still, we learned that:
his original Martian form was not as we see him;
he had not only teleported but also time traveled from an inhabited Mars in the distant past, just as Michael Moorcock's Michael Kane had had to time travel pastward to reach an inhabited Mars.
When J'onzz got his own series, his metamorphic power was developed fully for the first time, giving him multiple identities on Earth. In a black identity, he worked on the Kent farm to keep an eye on Kal-El, as he does in Smallville. In The Sandman, he sees Morpheus as a Martian deity.
Apparently it will emerge that he had been an inter-galactic manhunter working with Jor-El. Smallville: Labyrinth alludes to his Martian vulnerability to fire.
Tuesday, 27 May 2014
X-Men: Days Of Future Past
I am not even going to try to make sense of the time travel nonsense in this film.
If there is a Sentinels-dominated future and if Wolverine is sent from that future to 1973 to initiate a timeline without a Sentinels-dominated future and if he succeeds, then he initiates a timeline in which there are no fire-breathing Sentinels attacking Xavier. He does not initiate a timeline in which fire-breathing Sentinels are attacking Xavier but suddenly Sentinels and Xavier disappear (and, furthermore, the building they were in continues to exist but is empty). {Addendum: Thank you for the comment correcting my inconsistent spelling.}
If Xavier sends Wolverine back to 1973, then maybe Wolverine succeeds in initiating an alternative timeline diverging from 1973 but that does not change the fact that the Xavier who sent Wolverine back to 1973 remains in the undesirable timeline.
The film seems to treat different (earlier and later) times as different places existing at the same time!
How can Xavier possibly know to ask Wolverine, "What is the last thing you remember?"
Why does Wolverine's consciousness from the future remain in the present?
When his older mind entered his younger body, where did his younger mind go? (This question can be answered in more than one way. My problem is that the question is not even asked.)
The school had closed down. Does this sound as if Wolverine had gone back to a different past?
How come the school was functioning as normal again at the end of the film? We did not see anything to explain this.
If there is a Sentinels-dominated future and if Wolverine is sent from that future to 1973 to initiate a timeline without a Sentinels-dominated future and if he succeeds, then he initiates a timeline in which there are no fire-breathing Sentinels attacking Xavier. He does not initiate a timeline in which fire-breathing Sentinels are attacking Xavier but suddenly Sentinels and Xavier disappear (and, furthermore, the building they were in continues to exist but is empty). {Addendum: Thank you for the comment correcting my inconsistent spelling.}
If Xavier sends Wolverine back to 1973, then maybe Wolverine succeeds in initiating an alternative timeline diverging from 1973 but that does not change the fact that the Xavier who sent Wolverine back to 1973 remains in the undesirable timeline.
The film seems to treat different (earlier and later) times as different places existing at the same time!
How can Xavier possibly know to ask Wolverine, "What is the last thing you remember?"
Why does Wolverine's consciousness from the future remain in the present?
When his older mind entered his younger body, where did his younger mind go? (This question can be answered in more than one way. My problem is that the question is not even asked.)
The school had closed down. Does this sound as if Wolverine had gone back to a different past?
How come the school was functioning as normal again at the end of the film? We did not see anything to explain this.
Friday, 28 February 2014
West, Space And Time
Copied from Poul Anderson Appreciation:
This is one of those posts that starts somewhere else but works its way back to Poul Anderson.
In the early 1950's, I got the weekly British comic strip paper, The Eagle, even before I could read it. This comic featured "Dan Dare, Pilot of the Future" and "Riders of the Range," a Western series that had a fictitious central character but that also incorporated historical figures and events. I realized even then that, although I loved Westerns, I preferred pictures of men in spacesuits to pictures of cowboys on horseback, thus sf to Westerns.
Many of my contemporaries had the same enthusiasm for football that I had for Westerns and sf. Why do people have such strong, and different, interests from such an early age? I don't know.
Dare's main adversaries, the Treens, were bald, green, hostile, humanoid extraterrestrials, thus similar to Dominic Flandry's opponents, the Merseians. Dare was a preparation for Poul Anderson's Flandry - who sometimes also wears a spacesuit. Despite his mastery of many genres, Anderson never wrote Westerns, except a joke Hoka story with Gordon R Dickson. ER Burroughs, who is also relevant here, did write four Western novels. ERB wrote comic book type characters but in prose fiction, including sf.
In addition to a fascination with space travel, I also acquired slightly later on a very great fascination with two other sf ideas, time travel and future histories. Flandry, of course, is a major figure in a long future history series. My introduction to time travel was another comic strip, the Classics Illustrated adaptation of HG Wells' The Time Machine. And Wells' novel was a precursor to Anderson's Time Patrol.
This is one of those posts that starts somewhere else but works its way back to Poul Anderson.
In the early 1950's, I got the weekly British comic strip paper, The Eagle, even before I could read it. This comic featured "Dan Dare, Pilot of the Future" and "Riders of the Range," a Western series that had a fictitious central character but that also incorporated historical figures and events. I realized even then that, although I loved Westerns, I preferred pictures of men in spacesuits to pictures of cowboys on horseback, thus sf to Westerns.
Many of my contemporaries had the same enthusiasm for football that I had for Westerns and sf. Why do people have such strong, and different, interests from such an early age? I don't know.
Dare's main adversaries, the Treens, were bald, green, hostile, humanoid extraterrestrials, thus similar to Dominic Flandry's opponents, the Merseians. Dare was a preparation for Poul Anderson's Flandry - who sometimes also wears a spacesuit. Despite his mastery of many genres, Anderson never wrote Westerns, except a joke Hoka story with Gordon R Dickson. ER Burroughs, who is also relevant here, did write four Western novels. ERB wrote comic book type characters but in prose fiction, including sf.
In addition to a fascination with space travel, I also acquired slightly later on a very great fascination with two other sf ideas, time travel and future histories. Flandry, of course, is a major figure in a long future history series. My introduction to time travel was another comic strip, the Classics Illustrated adaptation of HG Wells' The Time Machine. And Wells' novel was a precursor to Anderson's Time Patrol.
Saturday, 18 January 2014
1956
In Eclipse Comics and again in Marvel Comics, a 1956 Mick Anglo Marvelman Family story is adapted as a Prologue to Miracleman. As I understand it, the writer of Miracleman changed some of the words but none of the art. For example, the opening words:
"PROLOGUE 1956 An age of lingering innocence, an age of golden dreams for the.. MIRACLEMAN FAMILY" (Miracleman, no 1 (New York, 2014), p. 1..."
- read like a rewrite.
The Marvelman Family story is a hopelessly inconsistent time travel story which, nevertheless, makes perfect sense in this context. (It will emerge that inconsistencies were deliberately built into the Family's early adventures to test their credulity and controllability.)
In the Prologue, the Science Gestapo attacks from 1981 whereas I am sure that, in the original, they came from many millennia in the future. However, this change makes sense because, in the 1980's, Miracleman will recall his adventures of the 1960's.
The story:
in 1981, the United Earth Government prevents Kommandant Garrer's Science Gestapo from enslaving the world;
the Gestapo travels in Chrono Cruisers to conquer instead the world of 1956;
a local compares the Chrono Cruisers to "...space rockets, just like in Dan Dare!" (p. 3), which strikes me as another rewrite;
Johnny Bates, happening along, transforms to Kid Miracleman and fights the invaders but more arrive so he goes at "...atomic speed..." (p. 4) for help;
Kid and Young batter the invaders who, however, recover unexpectedly quickly;
one trooper explains that the atomic storm troopers are arriving in other countries and we see them in Paris and Saigon;
Micky Moran reads stop-press news of the invasion and transforms to Miracleman;
the Miracleman Family and the Army subdue the first landing in Cornwall;
the Family split up to liberate Rome, Washington and Moscow, respectively;
the invaders in Cornwall recover and bombard the Army with "...rare magnetic gases from our secret video rings!" (p. 6) (words are sometimes used with no apparent knowledge of their meanings);
the Family returns to find fighting again in Cornwall;
Garrer orders his men to destroy the Chrono Cruisers, of which more are still arriving, so that he and his men cannot be returned to 1981;
leaving KM to fight in 1956, MM and YM travel "...at atomic speed..." (p. 8) to 1981 when they destroy the Chrono Cruisers before their departure, capture Garrer and hand him over to "...the Commander, Twelfth Area, World Police" (p. 10), who expresses no surprise and says that 1981 can now become a utopia;
ironically, MM hopes that he lives to see it;
in 1956, the atomic troopers fighting KM suddenly vanish!;
then, hearing MM's account, KM accepts instead that they were never there! - while MM jokes that "...that's the way it was...or was it?" (p. 10)
Hopeless:
if the Chrono Cruisers had already arrived in 1956, then destroying them before their departure in 1981 could not possibly prevent them from having already arrived in 1956;
if the Cruisers had not arrived in 1956, then MM and YM would not have traveled to 1981;
and, if the Cruisers had arrived in 1956, then there is no reason why the troopers fighting KM should suddenly disappear at some later time;
please do not tell me that they disappeared in 1956 at the exact same time as MM and YM destroyed the Chrono Cruisers in 1981! (Please don't!)
However, thanks to the ingenuity of the writer of Miracleman, we now know exactly what is really happening here. Gargunza is thinking, "They can even swallow that!"
"PROLOGUE 1956 An age of lingering innocence, an age of golden dreams for the.. MIRACLEMAN FAMILY" (Miracleman, no 1 (New York, 2014), p. 1..."
- read like a rewrite.
The Marvelman Family story is a hopelessly inconsistent time travel story which, nevertheless, makes perfect sense in this context. (It will emerge that inconsistencies were deliberately built into the Family's early adventures to test their credulity and controllability.)
In the Prologue, the Science Gestapo attacks from 1981 whereas I am sure that, in the original, they came from many millennia in the future. However, this change makes sense because, in the 1980's, Miracleman will recall his adventures of the 1960's.
The story:
in 1981, the United Earth Government prevents Kommandant Garrer's Science Gestapo from enslaving the world;
the Gestapo travels in Chrono Cruisers to conquer instead the world of 1956;
a local compares the Chrono Cruisers to "...space rockets, just like in Dan Dare!" (p. 3), which strikes me as another rewrite;
Johnny Bates, happening along, transforms to Kid Miracleman and fights the invaders but more arrive so he goes at "...atomic speed..." (p. 4) for help;
Kid and Young batter the invaders who, however, recover unexpectedly quickly;
one trooper explains that the atomic storm troopers are arriving in other countries and we see them in Paris and Saigon;
Micky Moran reads stop-press news of the invasion and transforms to Miracleman;
the Miracleman Family and the Army subdue the first landing in Cornwall;
the Family split up to liberate Rome, Washington and Moscow, respectively;
the invaders in Cornwall recover and bombard the Army with "...rare magnetic gases from our secret video rings!" (p. 6) (words are sometimes used with no apparent knowledge of their meanings);
the Family returns to find fighting again in Cornwall;
Garrer orders his men to destroy the Chrono Cruisers, of which more are still arriving, so that he and his men cannot be returned to 1981;
leaving KM to fight in 1956, MM and YM travel "...at atomic speed..." (p. 8) to 1981 when they destroy the Chrono Cruisers before their departure, capture Garrer and hand him over to "...the Commander, Twelfth Area, World Police" (p. 10), who expresses no surprise and says that 1981 can now become a utopia;
ironically, MM hopes that he lives to see it;
in 1956, the atomic troopers fighting KM suddenly vanish!;
then, hearing MM's account, KM accepts instead that they were never there! - while MM jokes that "...that's the way it was...or was it?" (p. 10)
Hopeless:
if the Chrono Cruisers had already arrived in 1956, then destroying them before their departure in 1981 could not possibly prevent them from having already arrived in 1956;
if the Cruisers had not arrived in 1956, then MM and YM would not have traveled to 1981;
and, if the Cruisers had arrived in 1956, then there is no reason why the troopers fighting KM should suddenly disappear at some later time;
please do not tell me that they disappeared in 1956 at the exact same time as MM and YM destroyed the Chrono Cruisers in 1981! (Please don't!)
However, thanks to the ingenuity of the writer of Miracleman, we now know exactly what is really happening here. Gargunza is thinking, "They can even swallow that!"
Wednesday, 15 January 2014
A Missed Connection
In the previous post, I mentioned modern continuations of the Arthurian legend, including Tolkien's unfinished poem and Lewis' and Gaiman's treatments of Merlin. I also contrasted Gaiman's time traveling Tim Hunter meeting the young Merlin with Lewis' space traveling Elwin Ransom meeting the revived Merlin and the undying Arthur. I thought that these were neat connections. To completely tie these three authors together, we can add that, of course, Tolkien and Lewis were friends and that both Lewis and Gaiman reference Tolkien in their fiction.
However, I missed a whole heap of other connections between Tolkien, Lewis, space travel, time travel, "Elwin" and Atlantis. (Tim Hunter also visits Atlantis.)
Lewis and Tolkien agreed that Lewis would write a space travel story, which became the first Ransom novel, and that Tolkien would write a time travel story - the unfinished The Lost Road, which would have taken its hero to Atlantis. A modern character was to have have been called "Elwin, "Elf-friend," whereas Ransom's "Elwin" means "friend of the eldila." Information about The Lost Road and about Numenor, Tolkien's version of Atlantis (referenced by Ransom), are in Volume V of The History Of Middle-earth by Christopher Tolkien.
Gaiman, through the DC Comics Atlantean magician Arion, rightly tells us that there are many Atlantises.
However, I missed a whole heap of other connections between Tolkien, Lewis, space travel, time travel, "Elwin" and Atlantis. (Tim Hunter also visits Atlantis.)
Lewis and Tolkien agreed that Lewis would write a space travel story, which became the first Ransom novel, and that Tolkien would write a time travel story - the unfinished The Lost Road, which would have taken its hero to Atlantis. A modern character was to have have been called "Elwin, "Elf-friend," whereas Ransom's "Elwin" means "friend of the eldila." Information about The Lost Road and about Numenor, Tolkien's version of Atlantis (referenced by Ransom), are in Volume V of The History Of Middle-earth by Christopher Tolkien.
Gaiman, through the DC Comics Atlantean magician Arion, rightly tells us that there are many Atlantises.
Saturday, 4 January 2014
A Little More On Time Travel
See here.
I said earlier that, in Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic series, the title of each individual volume is on the title page though not on the front cover. I see now that it is also on the spine but this is so thin as to be almost unnoticeable.
Volume IV, The Road To Nowhere, involves time travel. In any carefully written time travel story, it is necessary to heed any apparently inconsequential remarks that may turn out to be significant later. Of course, that is necessary in any fiction but time travel adds an extra dimension. A figure in the background of a scene may turn out to be a character who, later in the story, sets out to travel pastwards in order to observe or intervene in that earlier moment.
When Tim and Mr E pass through the sixtieth century, they are addressed by a disembodied voice that asks them where they are from and, when told "the past, the twentieth century," continues:
"We have a throwback to be punished/scolded/rehabilitated) not pleasing here [will you expropriate him to your time/?" (p. 21)
When Tim sounds uncertain, the voice, unconcerned, says that it has:
"...located your lodging date-line now ( will be jimdandy for the madchild...)" (ibid.)
So someone will be sent from the sixtieth to the twentieth century because, in the sixtieth, he is regarded as a throwback, as mad and as a child. Does this correspond to any known DC character? I thought that it might refer to Mr E walking back from the end of time. He is a throwback and mad though hardly a child but maybe he seems such in the sixtieth?
Booster Gold is a superhero of questionable maturity who has time traveled from (maybe it is the sixtieth?) to the twentieth century but this seems like a different scenario. (Later: No, the twenty-fifth.)
I said earlier that, in Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic series, the title of each individual volume is on the title page though not on the front cover. I see now that it is also on the spine but this is so thin as to be almost unnoticeable.
Volume IV, The Road To Nowhere, involves time travel. In any carefully written time travel story, it is necessary to heed any apparently inconsequential remarks that may turn out to be significant later. Of course, that is necessary in any fiction but time travel adds an extra dimension. A figure in the background of a scene may turn out to be a character who, later in the story, sets out to travel pastwards in order to observe or intervene in that earlier moment.
When Tim and Mr E pass through the sixtieth century, they are addressed by a disembodied voice that asks them where they are from and, when told "the past, the twentieth century," continues:
"We have a throwback to be punished/scolded/rehabilitated) not pleasing here [will you expropriate him to your time/?" (p. 21)
When Tim sounds uncertain, the voice, unconcerned, says that it has:
"...located your lodging date-line now ( will be jimdandy for the madchild...)" (ibid.)
So someone will be sent from the sixtieth to the twentieth century because, in the sixtieth, he is regarded as a throwback, as mad and as a child. Does this correspond to any known DC character? I thought that it might refer to Mr E walking back from the end of time. He is a throwback and mad though hardly a child but maybe he seems such in the sixtieth?
Booster Gold is a superhero of questionable maturity who has time traveled from (maybe it is the sixtieth?) to the twentieth century but this seems like a different scenario. (Later: No, the twenty-fifth.)
Thursday, 2 January 2014
Time Travel In The Books Of Magic III
See here.
In almost any narrative, whether factual or fictional, a causal sequence is also a linear temporal sequence. A caused B and also preceded B. Of course. We are so used to the identity between these two sequences that we expect it to continue even in a narrative featuring time travel.
In Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic: The Road To Nowhere (New York, 1991):
(i) Tim Hunter departs into the future with Mr E;
(ii) they fail to return;
(iii) increasingly concerned, E's colleagues send Tim's owl into the future to help him;
(iv) Tim returns...
(v) ...having been helped at the end of time both by the owl and by Death of the Endless.
(i)-(v) is an objective chronological sequence although, in Tim's subjective experience, (v) precedes (iv). Hence, the otherwise nonsensical phrase, "...having been helped (perfect tense) at the end of time (in the future)..."
We automatically accept that (iv) follows (iii). However, if Death had returned Tim to his starting point, then:
(i) Tim would have returned as he and E departed;
(ii) Tim would not have failed to return;
(iii) E's colleagues would have had no cause for concern and would not have sent the owl;
(iv) Tim would not have returned later;
(v) He would have been helped at the end of time only by Death.
However, Death saw the owl arrive in the future and therefore knew that she had to return Tim not to his starting point but to after the owl's starting point. This is circular causality: the owl was sent because Tim had not returned immediately and Tim had not returned immediately because the owl was sent.
In almost any narrative, whether factual or fictional, a causal sequence is also a linear temporal sequence. A caused B and also preceded B. Of course. We are so used to the identity between these two sequences that we expect it to continue even in a narrative featuring time travel.
In Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic: The Road To Nowhere (New York, 1991):
(i) Tim Hunter departs into the future with Mr E;
(ii) they fail to return;
(iii) increasingly concerned, E's colleagues send Tim's owl into the future to help him;
(iv) Tim returns...
(v) ...having been helped at the end of time both by the owl and by Death of the Endless.
(i)-(v) is an objective chronological sequence although, in Tim's subjective experience, (v) precedes (iv). Hence, the otherwise nonsensical phrase, "...having been helped (perfect tense) at the end of time (in the future)..."
We automatically accept that (iv) follows (iii). However, if Death had returned Tim to his starting point, then:
(i) Tim would have returned as he and E departed;
(ii) Tim would not have failed to return;
(iii) E's colleagues would have had no cause for concern and would not have sent the owl;
(iv) Tim would not have returned later;
(v) He would have been helped at the end of time only by Death.
However, Death saw the owl arrive in the future and therefore knew that she had to return Tim not to his starting point but to after the owl's starting point. This is circular causality: the owl was sent because Tim had not returned immediately and Tim had not returned immediately because the owl was sent.
Wednesday, 1 January 2014
Time Travel In The Books Of Magic II
See here.
In Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic, Book IV, The Road To Nowhere (New York, 1991), of the Trenchcoat Brigade, only Mr E can travel into the future but, when Tim Hunter has gone with E into the future and not returned, the remaining three manage to send Tim's owl to the rescue because of its affinity with Tim.
Doctor Occult tells the owl:
"Wherever [Tim] is...wherever he might be. Find him. Protect him. Help him." (p. 25)
This is a joint magical effort because Occult asks the Stranger for strength and Constantine for will and faith.
The owl must understand Occult. "Wherever..." should be something like, "Whenever he is now traveling to and will need help..."
At the end of time, Death tells E to walk all the way back, and it will take him a lot of subjective time to "walk" step by step through a hundred billion years, whereas she sends Tim "instantaneously," i. e., without any subjective duration experienced or endured by him. That might explain why the Stranger did not detect Tim's return but there is still E to be accounted for. At the end, the Trenchcoat Brigade speak as if they have lost E because he is "...making his own way back from the end of time..." (p. 44), whereas, of course, if he successfully returns from the future to the present, then he is now in the present, not still making his way back.
On the other hand, E said something to Tim which suggests that he might make it back to his starting point, then continue walking for a few decades more. In his childhood, he was taught how to walk through time by an old, blind man...
In Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic, Book IV, The Road To Nowhere (New York, 1991), of the Trenchcoat Brigade, only Mr E can travel into the future but, when Tim Hunter has gone with E into the future and not returned, the remaining three manage to send Tim's owl to the rescue because of its affinity with Tim.
Doctor Occult tells the owl:
"Wherever [Tim] is...wherever he might be. Find him. Protect him. Help him." (p. 25)
This is a joint magical effort because Occult asks the Stranger for strength and Constantine for will and faith.
The owl must understand Occult. "Wherever..." should be something like, "Whenever he is now traveling to and will need help..."
At the end of time, Death tells E to walk all the way back, and it will take him a lot of subjective time to "walk" step by step through a hundred billion years, whereas she sends Tim "instantaneously," i. e., without any subjective duration experienced or endured by him. That might explain why the Stranger did not detect Tim's return but there is still E to be accounted for. At the end, the Trenchcoat Brigade speak as if they have lost E because he is "...making his own way back from the end of time..." (p. 44), whereas, of course, if he successfully returns from the future to the present, then he is now in the present, not still making his way back.
On the other hand, E said something to Tim which suggests that he might make it back to his starting point, then continue walking for a few decades more. In his childhood, he was taught how to walk through time by an old, blind man...
Tuesday, 31 December 2013
The Books Of Magic, Book Four
The individual title of each volume of Neil Gaiman's The Books Of Magic is given on the title page but not on the front cover so they come as a surprise. Book Four is The Road To Nowhere (New York, 1991). Mr E and Timothy Hunter, like HG Wells' Time Traveler, visit the near, then the far, future.
When asked whether he can travel into the future, John Constantine replies:
"Only like everyone else, boss. You know. One minute at a time." (p. 4)
One minute per minute is enduring, not traveling. Travel requires two kinds of units, eg, one mile per minute. One objective century per one subjective minute would be time dilation, not time travel, although, in certain circumstances, this is called "time travel." I discuss this on the Logic of Time Travel Blog.
I think that E contradicts himself. He insists that they are truly in the future, but then unhelpfully adds "...or futures" (p. 5), but then says that what they are seeing is only a possibility that may never happen (p. 7). He describes the future as many possibilities, none of them definite, and explains that time travelers visit only the most probable. It follows that time travelers setting off from different times will travel through different futures. This contradicts Merlin in Book One definitely stating that his future was single, known by him and unalterable. I know that Merlin was in our past but he was talking about his future.
There will obviously be a lot more to post on this topic.
When asked whether he can travel into the future, John Constantine replies:
"Only like everyone else, boss. You know. One minute at a time." (p. 4)
One minute per minute is enduring, not traveling. Travel requires two kinds of units, eg, one mile per minute. One objective century per one subjective minute would be time dilation, not time travel, although, in certain circumstances, this is called "time travel." I discuss this on the Logic of Time Travel Blog.
I think that E contradicts himself. He insists that they are truly in the future, but then unhelpfully adds "...or futures" (p. 5), but then says that what they are seeing is only a possibility that may never happen (p. 7). He describes the future as many possibilities, none of them definite, and explains that time travelers visit only the most probable. It follows that time travelers setting off from different times will travel through different futures. This contradicts Merlin in Book One definitely stating that his future was single, known by him and unalterable. I know that Merlin was in our past but he was talking about his future.
There will obviously be a lot more to post on this topic.
Thursday, 19 December 2013
A Dream Of A Thousand Cats
Why was the cat-goddess, Bast, who appears later in Neil Gaiman's Sandman series, not involved in "A Dream Of A Thousand Cats"?
In a single short story, Gaiman envisages an entire alternative history in which cats were large and human beings were small. I do not think that this history has ever been imagined before or will be again. There is a cosmic conflict between cats and humanity although most members of both species remain unaware of it.
The cat universe exists not in our past but, I would say, in the past of a second temporal dimension, borrowing an idea from time travel fiction. But there are different ways of conceptualizing what Gaiman is trying to say and it is difficult to make any of them internally consistent.
When "...things changed..." and "Humans were huge..." (Dream Country, New York, 1995, p. 54), we see a cat between walking human legs on a pavement beside a parked car, as if a human-dominated world has just begun to exist full of fallacious memories and records of a human-dominated history. This is not quite what the characters say has happened but it is what is suggested by this panel. Is it possible?
Is it possible that you have just been created and that all your memories, created with you, are false and do not give you any knowledge of past events? Our experience of remembering is not like our experience of consulting a currently existing record of past events. Memory feels like direct acquaintance with past events but is it? Our brains could be manipulated to make us seem to remember something different.
In a single short story, Gaiman envisages an entire alternative history in which cats were large and human beings were small. I do not think that this history has ever been imagined before or will be again. There is a cosmic conflict between cats and humanity although most members of both species remain unaware of it.
The cat universe exists not in our past but, I would say, in the past of a second temporal dimension, borrowing an idea from time travel fiction. But there are different ways of conceptualizing what Gaiman is trying to say and it is difficult to make any of them internally consistent.
When "...things changed..." and "Humans were huge..." (Dream Country, New York, 1995, p. 54), we see a cat between walking human legs on a pavement beside a parked car, as if a human-dominated world has just begun to exist full of fallacious memories and records of a human-dominated history. This is not quite what the characters say has happened but it is what is suggested by this panel. Is it possible?
Is it possible that you have just been created and that all your memories, created with you, are false and do not give you any knowledge of past events? Our experience of remembering is not like our experience of consulting a currently existing record of past events. Memory feels like direct acquaintance with past events but is it? Our brains could be manipulated to make us seem to remember something different.
Monday, 13 May 2013
Kryptonian Anti-Gravity
Vision powers are explained by natural selection in Krypton's dense atmosphere and hostile environment but I also postulate interventions by the god Rao to maintain the human form despite evolutionary changes because his purpose was to generate a hero to be sent to Earth, and later into the cosmos, after the foredoomed destruction of Krypton.
Later: A spindizzy screen would explain faster than light interstellar flight but not time travel.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


















